"There is nothing honorable in honor killing or other atrocities and, in fact, it is nothing but barbaric and shameful. The time has come to stamp out these barbaric, feudal practices which are a slur on our nation.” - Justice Markandey Katju
Introduction
This Article is based on a practice which is most Cruel and neglected Practice of the Indian Society, though Judicial System is using all the proactive methods to throw it from the society but it will not be possible unless or until peoples mindset is Going to Change regarding Girls and Women's in society, very few people know about it, and very few take stand against this practice and it's sad to know the rising data's day by day. Author is talking about 'Honor Killing', it is one of the most important evil practice which is neglected by the members of Indian Society.
No doubt, in 21st Century People are having busy schedule, have very less time for other's but being a citizen of a diversified and a proud Nation, it's our Duty to throw away such evil practices from our society.
Definition:
Honor Killing is an evil act of murder of a family member generally, female member of the family by the male members of the family for bringing dishonor to the family. It can be by anything if a girl child have pre-marital affair, wants to marry person of another caste or with same gotra or have extra-marital affair, which becomes unacceptable to the family members and for bringing dishonor to the family by such acts, they punishes her by taking away her life. It's an cruel act usually done against women, in men this practice is followed quite less in number.
We say it's 21st Century with the development of Tech and AI, people's mindset is also enhancing but at ground level of Indian Society in most of the regions of North and South India, this evil practice is followed, where Female's are humiliated, tortured and Killed for the only reason, She tries to marry someone who don't belong to her caste, religion or belongs to same gotra, also there are other reasons like people consider Girl child puts an extra economic burden on their family so for that reason they kill the girl child.
I am Writing this Article in 2024 to make people aware about such inhuman crime is still practiced in our country and no institution, no political body talks about it, Honor Killing is always suppressed due to several reasons but now it's a time to bring an end to such evil crimes taking place in our Country.
Historical Overview
Let's Dive into the History to understand the cause of Honor Killing:
The Caste System: A Major Factor
Honor killings in India have deep historical roots, with the caste system being one of the most significant factors. The caste system, a hierarchical social stratification dating back thousands of years, has dictated social norms, including marriage and relationships. This rigid system categorizes individuals into distinct groups, typically determined by birth, and strictly prohibits inter-caste marriages. Violations of these norms are perceived as severe breaches of family honor, leading to extreme measures such as honor killings to restore the perceived loss of dignity and status.
Patriarchal Society and Gender Norms
India's patriarchal society has also significantly contributed to the prevalence of honor killings. In a patriarchal system, male dominance and control over women's choices, especially regarding marriage and sexuality, are paramount. Women are often seen as bearers of family honor, and any deviation from prescribed gender roles or defiance of family decisions in matters of love and marriage can lead to violent retribution. This patriarchal mindset, deeply ingrained in society, has historically sanctioned the use of honor killings as a means to control and subjugate women.
Historical Precedents and Cultural Norms
Historical precedents in Indian culture and customs have further fueled the practice of honor killings. Traditional customs such as 'Kanyadaan' (the giving away of the bride) emphasize the control and transfer of a woman's autonomy from her father to her husband. Marriages were often arranged to preserve family lineage, social status, and community ties. The notion of 'family honor' became intertwined with women's conduct, leading to punitive actions against those who challenged these established norms.
In rural India, community councils known as Khap Panchayats have played a controversial role in perpetuating honor killings. These councils, often composed of elder men from dominant castes, enforce traditional codes of conduct and have been known to sanction honor killings to maintain social order. Historically, these bodies wielded significant power and were instrumental in reinforcing caste and gender norms.
Inter-Religious Marriages and Social Taboos
Apart from caste considerations, inter-religious marriages have also been a cause of honor killings in India. Marriages between individuals from different religious backgrounds are often seen as a threat to cultural purity and family honor. Historical tensions between religious communities, coupled with societal taboos against inter-religious unions, have led to violent repercussions for those who dare to cross these boundaries.
Economic and Social Status
Economic considerations have historically influenced honor killings. Marriages within the same caste or community often ensured the continuation of family wealth and social status. When individuals chose partners outside their prescribed social group, it was seen as a potential loss of economic stability and social prestige, prompting families to resort to honor killings to prevent such unions and protect their assets.
Historical Examples
Throughout history, there have been numerous documented cases of honor killings that reflect these societal norms. For instance, the infamous case of Phoolan Devi, the 'Bandit Queen,' who was targeted for defying traditional gender roles and caste norms, highlights the extreme measures taken to uphold family and caste honor. While not all instances reached the public eye, countless cases over centuries have demonstrated the lethal consequences of defying societal expectations.
Statements On Caste system and Honor Killing:
Various Prominent Persons Gave there opinion on Caste system and Honor Killing in India, Let's Understand what they stated:
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, the principal architect of the Indian Constitution, was a staunch critic of the caste system and its associated practices. While he did not specifically address honor killings in the modern context, his writings and speeches vehemently condemned the social inequalities and atrocities that stemmed from caste-based discrimination. He stated, “Caste is not a physical object like a wall of bricks or a line of barbed wire which prevents the Hindus from co-mingling and which has, therefore, to be pulled down. Caste is a notion; it is a state of the mind.” Ambedkar's relentless advocacy for social reform laid the foundation for challenging practices like honor killings that are deeply rooted in caste-based prejudices.
Mahatma Gandhi
Mahatma Gandhi, the leader of the Indian independence movement, also spoke out against the rigid caste system and the social injustices it propagated. Though he did not specifically mention honor killings, he advocated for the upliftment and equality of all castes, especially the 'Harijans' or 'untouchables.' He said, “I believe in the essential unity of man and for that matter, of all that lives. Therefore, I believe that if one man gains spiritually, the whole world gains with him, and if one man falls, the whole world falls to that extent.” Gandhi’s vision of a caste-free society directly challenges the notion of honor killings that seek to enforce caste boundaries.
Jawaharlal Nehru
Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first Prime Minister, was a vocal advocate for social reforms and gender equality. He criticized the oppressive practices against women and lower castes. In his book “The Discovery of India,” Nehru expressed his disdain for regressive traditions that hindered social progress. He stated, “The nation that oppresses its women, that does not respect them, that does not put them on a level with men, can never rise and be worthy of pride.” His vision for a modern, progressive India included the eradication of practices such as honor killings, which he saw as incompatible with the principles of equality and human dignity.
Indira Gandhi
Indira Gandhi, the first and only female Prime Minister of India, spoke extensively about the need for women’s empowerment and social reform. While she did not specifically address honor killings frequently, her policies and speeches reflected a commitment to gender equality and social justice. She once remarked, “To be liberated, woman must feel free to be herself, not in rivalry to man but in the context of her own capacity and her personality.” Her leadership emphasized the importance of dismantling patriarchal structures that perpetuate violence against women, including honor killings.
Smt. Pratibha Patil
Smt. Pratibha Patil, the first woman President of India, has explicitly condemned honor killings. During her tenure, she emphasized the need for strict legal measures and societal change to combat this heinous practice. She stated, “Honor killings are a disgrace to our society. They reflect the darkest and most regressive aspects of our traditions. We must ensure that such acts are met with the strongest legal action and that we work tirelessly to change the mindsets that justify these killings.”
Justice Markandey Katju
Justice Markandey Katju, a former judge of the Supreme Court of India, has been an outspoken critic of honor killings. He has called for stringent action against those involved in such crimes. In one of his judgments, he observed, “There is nothing honorable in honor killing or other atrocities and, in fact, it is nothing but barbaric and shameful. The time has come to stamp out these barbaric, feudal practices which are a slur on our nation.”
Statements from Activists and Public Figures
Various activists and public figures have also spoken out against honor killings. Notably, Kiran Bedi, the first female officer in the Indian Police Service, has actively campaigned against such practices, emphasizing the role of law enforcement and legal reforms. She has stated, “Honor killings are a blot on our society. It is imperative that we use the full force of the law to punish the perpetrators and work towards changing the societal attitudes that condone such violence.”
Judicial System on Honor Killing
The Stand of the Judicial System on Honor Killings in Today's Society in India:
Strong Condemnation and Legal Measures
The judicial system in India has taken a firm and unequivocal stand against honor killings, recognizing them as severe violations of human rights and fundamental freedoms. The Supreme Court and various High Courts have consistently condemned these acts and have mandated stringent legal measures to combat this practice.
Supreme Court's Stance
The Supreme Court of India has delivered landmark judgments that strongly denounce honor killings and have set precedents for lower courts to follow. In the case of Shakti Vahini v. Union of India (2018), the Supreme Court explicitly addressed the issue of honor killings. The Court stated that honor killings are nothing but barbaric and feudal practices that violate the constitutional rights of individuals. It emphasized that such acts are punishable under the law and directed the state governments and law enforcement agencies to take proactive measures to prevent these crimes.
The Court outlined several measures, including:
- Establishing special cells in every district to provide protection to couples facing threats.
- Setting up fast-track courts to expedite trials of honor killing cases.
- Ensuring that police officers take immediate action to protect individuals who are at risk and prosecute the offenders.
High Courts' Responses
Various High Courts in India have also played a crucial role in combating honor killings. They have passed numerous judgments reinforcing the Supreme Court's directives and have often taken suo motu cognizance of such cases to ensure justice is served. For instance:
- The Punjab and Haryana High Court has been particularly active given the prevalence of honor killings in the region. It has called for stringent action against Khap Panchayats (community councils) that endorse or facilitate honor killings.
- The Allahabad High Court has issued orders to provide police protection to couples facing threats due to inter-caste or inter-religious marriages.
Legal Framework and Enforcement
The Indian Penal Code (IPC) does not specifically mention honor killings, but various sections are applied to prosecute these crimes:
- Section 299-304: Addressing culpable homicide and murder.
- Section 307: Attempt to murder.
- Section 120A and 120B: Criminal conspiracy.
- Section 34 and 35: Acts done by several persons in furtherance of common intention.
Additionally, the judiciary has urged for amendments and the introduction of specific laws to deal with honor killings comprehensively. This includes recommendations for harsher punishments and clearer definitions to ensure that all perpetrators, including family members and community leaders, are held accountable.
Protection and Support Mechanisms
Recognizing the need for victim protection, the judiciary has advocated for several support mechanisms:
- Protection Orders: Courts can issue protection orders to safeguard individuals at risk.
- Safe Houses: Establishing safe houses where threatened couples can seek refuge.
- Witness Protection: Ensuring that witnesses in honor killing cases are provided adequate protection to testify without fear of retribution.
Public Awareness and Education
The judiciary has also emphasized the importance of public awareness and education to combat the deep-seated cultural norms that perpetuate honor killings. Judicial pronouncements often include directives to the government and NGOs to conduct awareness campaigns, promote gender equality, and educate communities about the legal rights of individuals.
The judicial system in India has taken a proactive and robust stand against honor killings. Through landmark judgments, strict enforcement of existing laws, advocacy for new legislation, and the implementation of protective measures, the judiciary aims to eradicate this barbaric practice. The combined efforts of the courts, law enforcement agencies, and civil society are essential to challenge the underlying societal norms and ensure that the constitutional rights to life, liberty, and equality are upheld for all individuals, regardless of their caste, religion, or gender.
Mindset Matters:
In the heart of countless Indian communities, the ancient shadows of tradition and honor still cast a dark veil over the lives of many, fueling a mindset that permits the most tragic of cruelties—honor killings. It is a twisted paradox where love and freedom are shackled by the very fabric of societal norms meant to protect and uplift. The perpetrators, often family members, are driven by an insidious belief that their actions are justified, that the blood they spill somehow purifies their tarnished honor. This mindset, deeply rooted in a fear of shame and a desperate clinging to outdated customs, blinds them to the sanctity of life and the boundless beauty of individual choice. It transforms homes into battlegrounds and sanctuaries into places of unspeakable horror. The cries of those who dared to love across forbidden lines echo in the silent complicity of a society that, at times, looks away. It is a call to our collective conscience, urging us to rise against this inherited brutality, to foster a culture where honor is redefined not by the adherence to archaic rules, but by the courage to protect and cherish every human life.
In nutshell, Honor killings represent a grave violation of human rights and fundamental freedoms in India. While legal and judicial measures are crucial in combating this practice, addressing the underlying societal norms and values is equally important. A combined effort from the government, judiciary, civil society, and communities is essential to eradicate honor killings and promote a culture of respect for individual rights and freedoms.
Follow Legalkhabar.online For more Articles on Various Topics, News Updates, Current Affairs, Law Subject Notes, Articles on Govt. Exams etc.
Abhay Yadav
Noida
Thanks fornthe information.
ReplyDeleteIt was helpful 👍🏻
👍
Delete